The Trading of Rafael Devers and The Controversy That Surrounds it
Christopher Smith
July 03, 2025
On June 15, 2025, the Boston Red Sox traded homegrown superstar Rafael Devers to the San Francisco Giants in exchange for pitchers Kyle Harrison and Jordan Hicks, along with minor league prospects James Tibbs III and Jose Bello. The trade sparked immediate controversy. Many fans — and even some within the Red Sox organization — were left shocked and heartbroken, feeling that the team had essentially given away a franchise player. But what about the other side of the story?
Throughout the 2025 season, many have questioned whether Devers was truly a team player — especially for a guy carrying a $313.5 million contract extension. Devers played as the designated hitter (DH) all season, something he’d never done before, and according to reports, getting him to accept that role was no easy task. Devers has long been vocal that “his position” was third base. Some speculate that he felt disrespected after Boston signed third baseman Alex Bregman in the offseason — a move that made sense for the Red Sox, especially considering that Devers has statistically been one of the worst defensive third basemen in baseball in recent years.
Before the trade, Devers was asked about shifting to first base after starter Triston Casas went down with an injury. Reports suggest he seemed unwilling to make the move. Ironically, since arriving in San Francisco, Devers now says he’s willing to play “wherever” the Giants need him.
Red Sox legend David Ortiz (Big Papi) didn’t hold back in his comments about Devers after the trade, pointing to leadership and maturity issues that may have held Devers back from reaching his full potential in Boston.
From the Red Sox front office perspective, this move was about planning for the long term. If things go right, we might not see the benefits of this trade for a few years — but there are some bright spots even this season. The money saved from moving Devers' massive contract opens the door for Boston to pick up more weapons before the trade deadline.Some critics argue that Boston could have afforded to keep Devers and still spend big, but this deal seems to have sent a message: The Boston Red Sox are a team-first organization. If you want to wear the uniform and play in front of the Fenway faithful, you need to be all-in, all the time.
Devers was the last remaining player from the historical 2018 Red Sox team that won 108 games and the World Series. His departure was sad, but there is a silver lining. This trade signals the organization’s faith in the next generation. With exciting young prospects like Marcelo Mayer, Kristian Campbell, and Roman Anthony, the Red Sox seem to be building something new. If the front office can successfully develop and surround these young players with the right pieces, the future could be very bright for Boston baseball.
Christopher Smith is a Littleton High School graduate and will be majoring in journalism at the University of Missouri in the fall
Throughout the 2025 season, many have questioned whether Devers was truly a team player — especially for a guy carrying a $313.5 million contract extension. Devers played as the designated hitter (DH) all season, something he’d never done before, and according to reports, getting him to accept that role was no easy task. Devers has long been vocal that “his position” was third base. Some speculate that he felt disrespected after Boston signed third baseman Alex Bregman in the offseason — a move that made sense for the Red Sox, especially considering that Devers has statistically been one of the worst defensive third basemen in baseball in recent years.
Before the trade, Devers was asked about shifting to first base after starter Triston Casas went down with an injury. Reports suggest he seemed unwilling to make the move. Ironically, since arriving in San Francisco, Devers now says he’s willing to play “wherever” the Giants need him.
Red Sox legend David Ortiz (Big Papi) didn’t hold back in his comments about Devers after the trade, pointing to leadership and maturity issues that may have held Devers back from reaching his full potential in Boston.
From the Red Sox front office perspective, this move was about planning for the long term. If things go right, we might not see the benefits of this trade for a few years — but there are some bright spots even this season. The money saved from moving Devers' massive contract opens the door for Boston to pick up more weapons before the trade deadline.Some critics argue that Boston could have afforded to keep Devers and still spend big, but this deal seems to have sent a message: The Boston Red Sox are a team-first organization. If you want to wear the uniform and play in front of the Fenway faithful, you need to be all-in, all the time.
Devers was the last remaining player from the historical 2018 Red Sox team that won 108 games and the World Series. His departure was sad, but there is a silver lining. This trade signals the organization’s faith in the next generation. With exciting young prospects like Marcelo Mayer, Kristian Campbell, and Roman Anthony, the Red Sox seem to be building something new. If the front office can successfully develop and surround these young players with the right pieces, the future could be very bright for Boston baseball.
Christopher Smith is a Littleton High School graduate and will be majoring in journalism at the University of Missouri in the fall
Have a story?
Let's hear it!
(802) 757-2773
(603) 787-2444
news@thebridgeweekly.com