By Joseph A. Citro
THE BALSAMS’S GHOSTS
Most New Englanders remember the Balsams Grand Resort Hotel in Dixville Notch, New Hampshire. Once a famed getaway, the Balsams was a city unto itself, existing deep in the North Country wilderness, ten miles from the nearest town.
Today, there is something surreal about this once-magnificent grand hotel. It appears like a Victorian space station that touched down amid the great North Woods.
Located on 15,000 acres and surrounded by 800-foot cliffs, it’s difficult to imagine a location more conducive to the centuries-old pastime of contemplating nature.
But here we may contemplate supernature as well. At one time the Balsams housed a population of ghosts! And quite possibly… it still does!
I visited the Balsams some years ago and was delighted to discover its wonderfully active otherworldly guest list. And—wonder of wonders—the well-trained staff members were not sworn to secrecy about their ethereal antics!
Then President and Managing Partner Stephen P. Barba—who’d worked there since 1959—not only talked about the ghosts, but had been carefully documenting their activity for years.
“The number of reports [of ghosts] has greatly increased since we began our renovation program fifteen years ago,” Steve told me.
Although he had never seen one himself, Steve didn’t discount the testimony of the many employees and guests who’d had supernatural run-ins. “There are several staff members who report seeing ghosts,” Steve told me. “We have a bellhop who will never go to the third floor…”
In the summer of 1997, Steve said, doorman Wesley Richardson was heading up to the third floor, to room 439. Halfway up the last flight of stairs, he looked up and saw a beautiful woman sitting in a chair on the third-floor landing. At first, he thought she was a guest, but then he realized she was a ghost. When he considered the hour—almost midnight—her clothing—a long, black, outdated dress—and her fixed stare, what else could she be?
She didn’t seem to notice him or the sound of his footsteps. Just as Mr. Richardson began to turn away, the beautiful woman vanished.
#
A similar encounter involved a young businessman. He thought he was alone in the John Dix social parlor, when he heard the delighted laughter of a young woman. Enchanted, he began looking around for her. Much to his disappointment, she was nowhere to be seen. Later, returning to his room, he passed a large mirror in the corridor. In its dim depths, he saw the reflection of someone behind him: an extraordinarily beautiful young woman in a long, formal gown. She, and the clothing she wore, seemed strangely old-fashioned.
The young man quickly turned around to face her, but the hall was empty.
This lovely apparition had been reported many times in different parts of the hotel. Though she was often glimpsed in mirrors, she was also spotted sitting in chairs, standing in dark corners, and, on occasion, in plain sight. She has even appeared in the main lobby.
#
Steve took me to one of the several allegedly haunted rooms: Number 120. When we arrived, a housekeeper, who had just finished cleaning, was locking the door from outside. Though we all knew the room was empty, we could plainly hear movement and talking within. Steve smiled, placing his ear against the door.
“You hear that?” he said.
Unbelievably, I did.
Just to be sure, Steve knocked before unlocking the door. Sure enough, the room was absolutely empty.
After we’d stepped inside, he told me what had happened there.
On February 17, 1995, at 12:30 in the morning, a lady awoke to find a naked man at the foot of her bed. Moonlight revealed that he was dripping wet from head to toe.
At first, she thought it was her husband, fresh out of the shower. She called to him, “Honey, are you all right?”
The answer came from under the bedclothes right beside her.
She quickly understood that the intruder was not corporeal; it faded away as she watched. Just before it had vanished completely, her husband, a sergeant in the Massachusetts State Police, glimpsed it too.
Afterwards, Steve Barba did a little research that revealed two possibly relevant details: First, back in the era of the big bands—the 1930s—that was the room in which band leaders routinely stayed. And second, a certain band leader had drowned in Lake Gloriette, on the grounds of the hotel.
#
Jacques Couture, an occasional employee of the hotel, was convinced the place had not one, not two, but a small population of ethereal residents, some of which he had personally seen. On November 15, 1995, for example, he was standing in the Captain’s Study talking with Diane Hall. As Jacques looked over Diane’s shoulder, in the direction of the Sun Room, he saw something mysterious. An apparition slowly materialized right before his eyes. It appeared, he said, standing directly in front of the outside door. Though the features were indistinct, he was pretty sure it was a man.
In an effort not to seem surprised, and without saying anything, Jacques tried to signal for Diane to look, too. But before he could touch her shoulder, the apparition vanished.
Jacques also reported an accompanying physical sensation; he said he suddenly felt very cold.
These are but a few of the myriad curious encounters at what was once New Hampshire’s most venerable haunted hotel. Nature? Supernature? Who knows? They both seemed perfectly intertwined at the Balsams.
We can’t help but wonder what is going on there today. The hotel has been closed since 2011. Has it become a ghost itself? Or is it business-as-usual within the abandoned buildings, with phantom guests checking in and out and ethereal employees keeping the place just as it has always been?
THE MYSTERY OF MUDGETT’S TOMB
On a dark, blustery July morning in 1890, four cowboys brought a young Vermonter home.
When the train stopped at Cambridge Junction, two masked men jumped off. With icy stares and six-guns, they held inquisitive citizens at bay. Meanwhile, two more masked men removed a box from the baggage car—a casket.
None of the locals were allowed to touch or examine the box as the strangers loaded it onto a wagon and hauled it to the North Cambridge Cemetery. Folks said it seemed awfully heavy for a coffin.
The undertaker was paid to dig the grave two feet deeper than usual. After the masked men oversaw the interment, the grave was secured with a huge slab of concrete. Then earth. An oversized gravestone weighing more than three tons topped the whole thing—the biggest stone in the entire graveyard.
Needless to say, the pistol-packin’ pomp and circumstance provoked a lot of questions—questions that remain unanswered to this day.
Was it simply an errant native son returned to Vermont for burial? Or was something else sealed permanently in Charles H. Mudgett’s grave?
Speculation ran wild. Why would strangers from the Wild West require masks? Who were they? And what was really buried in the grave?
The answer may be carved in stone.
At first sight, the oversized headstone seems normal enough; it must have cost a great deal. Yet the expense wasn’t borne by the Mudgett family, but rather by Milton E. Milner of Montana.
A closer look at the monument itself reveals puzzles. The stone is covered with words, poetry, Latin, and odd symbols, in no discernible pattern. Some have guessed it may be some kind of cipher.
Strange too, that Mr. Milner’s name appears several times on the tomb. After all, Charles Mudgett was supposedly buried all by himself in the fifteen-by-twenty-foot plot.
Over more than a century since his interment, there has been a lot of conjecture about what it all means. The mysterious grave has taken on a certain "atmosphere." Some people avoid it; children won't set foot within the stone perimeter.
#
Local lore is full of conjecture, but no one knows anything for sure. One theory that seems to connect most of the puzzling elements is that something other than Charles H. Mudgett’s body lies below that mysterious monument and cement slab. Some are convinced a treasure is buried there. If so, that would explain the armed guard and the heavier-than-usual casket.
The same theorists argue that the men were all masked to screen the fact that without a disguise one of them would have been recognizable. Most likely that masked man was, in fact, Charles H. Mudgett himself.
Maybe “Charlie,” who had always been the black sheep of the Mudgett clan, had gone west and amassed a fortune in ill-gotten gains. Then, to escape jail or even hanging, he had concocted the death story to switch identities: in short, maybe Mudgett became Milner. The hometown burial would have two effects: it would stop Vermont relatives from going west to look for Charlie, and it would give him a nest egg to return to if, at some point, he were to come back to Vermont.
If there really was a Milton Everett Milner, not much, if anything, is known about him. One local story holds that Mr. Milner was the owner of the Montana ranch where young Mudgett met his death by drowning. This bachelor rancher might have been Mudgett's employer. Supposedly he'd taken the young Vermonter under his wing and—because Charlie had died "in the execution of his duty"—had borne the expense of returning him home to his family.
The odd gravestone markings, then, might be nothing more than the brands associated with Milner's cattle ranch. But if that were the case, local theorists argue, why the masks, guns, and overly-protected coffin?
And why would Milner want his name on the tomb?
More to the point, after the effort of returning him home, why wasn't "Charlie" buried with his family? He's all alone in the fifteen-by-twenty-foot plot with no other members of his clan. The rest of the Mudgetts lie elsewhere.
There are probably a hundred other scenarios to fit the odd assortment of details surrounding the mystery of Charles H. Mudgett. No one has ever opened the grave to get a definitive solution.
Today, as in 1890, the answer, if any, lies buried two feet deeper than usual, under several tons of granite, concrete, and earth.
Joseph A. Citro is a Vermont author and folklorist known for collecting New England’s ghost stories, legends, and strange-but-true lore. His most recent book is The Vermont Ghost Experience, available at local bookstores or wherever books are sold. You can also ask your local library to order it for your enjoyment and the enjoyment of other library patrons. In Passing Strange, Citro shares folklore with a curious eye, a storyteller’s warmth, and just enough mystery to make you look twice on the ride home.